Tafsir LabMethodGitHubTürkçe

Ṣād 38:86-88

The Qurʾān · Sūra 38: Ṣād · verses 86-88

This commentary was written by Claude (Anthropic); it carries no religious authority and should be checked against the classical sources.

38/86-88

قُلْ مَآ أَسْـَٔلُكُمْ عَلَيْهِ مِنْ أَجْرٍ وَمَآ أَنَا۠ مِنَ ٱلْمُتَكَلِّفِينَ · إِنْ هُوَ إِلَّا ذِكْرٌ لِّلْعَٰلَمِينَ · وَلَتَعْلَمُنَّ نَبَأَهُۥ بَعْدَ حِينٍۭ

Qul mā asʾalukum ʿalayhi min ajrin wa mā ana mina'l-mutakallifīn · In huwa illā dhikrun li'l-ʿālamīn · Wa la-taʿlamunna nabaʾahū baʿda ḥīn

"Say: I ask you no wage for this, and I am not one of those who contrive. It is nothing but a reminder for all the worlds. And you will surely know its report after a time."

مَآ أَسْـَٔلُكُمْ عَلَيْهِ مِنْ أَجْرٍ — no wage

أَجْر — root أ-ج-ر: the return for a work, a wage. And the concrete sense of the root: the knitting of a broken bone (ajara'l-ʿaẓmu). The lexicographers make the link thus: a wage is what "mends" the labour spent.

And the pattern of negation is strong: mā asʾalukum… min ajr — with min intervening, generalising as to kind: "no wage whatever".

The Qurʾān repeats this sentence in the mouths of many envoys (al-Shuʿarāʾ 26/109, 127, 145, 164, 180; Yūnus 10/72; Hūd 11/29, 51, and others). This, that is, is the common declaration of envoyship.

I record this as my own reading, and its ground is the ninth and tenth verses of the sūra: there the other side was asked "are the treasuries with you, is the dominion yours?" In the eighty-sixth verse the envoy says that on his own side too there is no expectation of a treasury or a dominion. The sūra closes the question of authority on both sides.

ٱلْمُتَكَلِّفِين — those who contrive something of their own

تَكَلَّفَ — root ك-ل-ف. Its concrete sense: to load a thing on oneself by force, to make it one's own burden. Kulfa — trouble; takallufto make a show of having what one has not, to force a thing.

The word conveys two things in Arabic:

SenseWhat it means
StrainingTo try to do what is not in one's power
AffectationTo appear other than one is; to add something of one's own

And the two senses meet in this verse.

Now a link is made with the seventh verse of the sūra, and this link is my own reading:

In the seventh verse the other side had said: in hādhā illā ikhtilāq — "this is nothing but a fabrication."

In the eighty-sixth verse the envoy says: wa mā ana mina'l-mutakallifīn — "I am not one of those who contrive something of their own."

The two words are from different roots (خ-ل-ق and ك-ل-ف) but they take up the same accusation. And the sūra answers the accusation eighty verses later.

Worth recording: the answer is not a defence but a refusal. "I do not fabricate" — and no ground is given. The ground is offered in the next verse as the Book itself.

إِنْ هُوَ إِلَّا ذِكْرٌ لِّلْعَٰلَمِينَ — the last name of the Book

And the backbone root of the sūra comes for the last time: ذ-ك-ر. It was tabulated above — the last of eight occurrences.

And the ring closes:

VerseExpression
1wa'l-Qurʾāni dhi'dh-dhikr — by the Qurʾān, possessor of the reminder
49hādhā dhikr — this is a reminder
87in huwa illā dhikrun li'l-ʿālamīn — it is a reminder for all the worlds

This is a frame that can be verified from the text.

And the note li'l-ʿālamīn is new: in the first verse the Book was named only dhi'dh-dhikr; here those it addresses are stated: all the worlds.

عَالَمِين — root ع-ل-م: to know. ʿĀlam — that by which something is known; a set of existing things. This word was treated in al-Fātiḥa.

I record this as my own reading: through the sūra those addressed had been narrow — the leading men of Mecca, a community, an envoy. In the last verses the compass opens. And this widening is the exact counterpart of the objection in the fourth verse: there it was said min bayninā ("from among us") — a narrow frame. Here li'l-ʿālamīn — the widest frame.

وَلَتَعْلَمُنَّ نَبَأَهُۥ بَعْدَ حِينٍۭ — the last sentence of the sūra

And the sūra closes with a sentence about knowing.

The construction of the sentence must be recorded: la-taʿlamunnalām + the nūn of emphasis.

As was recorded above in the table of the jawāb al-qasam, this pattern is the most established form of an oath's answer in Arabic. And some exegetes find the answer to the oath of the first verse here. I tabulated that view there; I do not impose a preference, but I record the force of the wording once more.

نَبَأ — and the word comes for the third and last time in the sūra:

VerseExpressionReport of what
21hal atāka nabaʾu'l-khaṣmOf the litigants — an account
67huwa nabaʾun ʿaẓīmA mighty report
88wa la-taʿlamunna nabaʾahū baʿda ḥīnIts report

Three occurrences, and all three together with a verb of hearing / knowing: atāka (has it reached you), qul (say), la-taʿlamunna (you will know).

I record this as my own reading: the sūra first offers the report with a question (21), then announces its greatness (67), and at the end ties the knowing of it to a time (88).

بَعْدَ حِينٍ — "after a time"

حِين — root ح-ي-ن: an indefinite stretch of time. And this is the distinguishing side of the word: its length is not specified. It may be a moment, or it may be a long age.

And the word occurs for the second time in the sūra. In the third verse it was said: wa-lāta ḥīna manāṣ — "it was no longer the hour of escape."

VerseExpressionWhat it conveys
3wa-lāta ḥīna manāṣThe hour had passed — being late
88baʿda ḥīnThe hour will come — waiting

This is a shared wording that can be verified, and it binds the beginning of the sūra to its end.

And it joins with the eighth verse as well: bal lammā yadhūqū ʿadhāb — "they have not yet tasted the punishment." There lammā conveyed an expectation; here that expectation is given its name: baʿda ḥīn.

I record this as my own reading, and its ground is the wording of these three verses (3, 8, 88): from beginning to end the sūra dwells on an interval of time. Knowing is not refused; it is deferred. And the mood of the sentence says this plainly: la-taʿlamunna"you will surely know". Whether it will be known is not the matter in dispute; when it will be known is.

On the last sentence of the sūra

And one last observation.

The sūra does not end with a threat. There is a warning in the last sentence, but the predicate of the sentence is not ʿadhāb or ʿiqāb — it is to know.

This can be compared with the close recorded in Qāf at 50/45: there too the sūra does not end with a frightening, and the last command was a reminding.

SūraThe predicate of the last sentenceWhat it conveys
Qāf 50/45fa-dhakkir bi'l-QurʾānA command — to the envoy
Ṣād 38/88wa la-taʿlamunna nabaʾahA report — to the one addressed

The two sūras look in two different directions: Qāf tells the envoy what he is to do, Ṣād tells the one addressed what will happen.


The whole of Sūrat Ṣād