Tafsir LabMethodGitHubTürkçe

al-Fajr 89:4

The Qurʾān · Sūra 89: al-Fajr · verse 4

This commentary was written by Claude (Anthropic); it carries no religious authority and should be checked against the classical sources.

89/4

وَٱلَّيْلِ إِذَا يَسْرِ

Wa'l-layli idhā yasr "And by the night when it travels on."

سَرَى — to travel by night

Root: س-ر-ي. Its meaning is not merely "to travel": to make one's way by night. Arabic has other verbs for travelling by day; sarā is specifically a journey made at night.

From the same root comes إسراء (isrāʾ), and it occurs in the Qurʾān: "It is He who made His servant travel by night" (al-Isrāʾ 17/1). The verb is asrā: He made him travel by night.

This feature of the word makes the choice in the verse meaningful: the night is not "coming" or "falling", it is travelling. And a thing that travels goes from somewhere to somewhere; it has a road, it has an end.

This is not a figure of personification — this is the word's own usage; in Arabic it is an ordinary expression for the night to sarā. But the effect is this: the night here is not a condition but a traveller. And a traveller will arrive.

Where it will arrive has also been stated: at the first verse. The place the night arrives at is the dawn. The first and the fourth verses of the sūra hold the two ends of the same event — one the moment at which the night ends, the other the journey that ends the night.

The four verbs of the night in the Qurʾān

The Qurʾān does not use a single verb when it mentions the night. Four separate oaths in the short Meccan sūras give four separate images:

VerseVerbWhat it says
al-Shams 91/4yaghshā-hā — it coversThe night is a covering; it comes over and closes
al-Layl 92/1yaghshā — it covers (without an object)The same verb, its object not stated
al-Ḍuḥā 93/2sajā — it grew still, it subsidedThe night is a stillness; movement stops
al-Takwīr 81/17ʿasʿasa — it came / it turned its backThe word conveys both coming and going (of the aḍdād)
al-Fajr 89/4yasri — it travelsThe night is a traveller; it makes its way and arrives

As was treated in the sections on al-Shams and al-Layl, the root gh-sh-y conveyed covering, enveloping, coming over and mantling; there the night was something that actively settles over you. Here the same night is something that goes its own way.

The difference matters. A covering night looks permanent — when has something settled over you is going to lift is not known. A travelling night is temporary; a thing that travels stops somewhere.

Considering the content of the sūra, this choice takes on meaning: al-Fajr will speak of peoples that were destroyed and of a man who sways. What is said of both is the same — it is temporary. That the night is travelling is the first record of this idea. I present this as my own reading.

The dropping of the final yāʾ

The original of the verb is يَسْرِي (yasrī) — imperfect, with a yāʾ at the end. In the verse it comes in the form يَسْرِ, without the yāʾ.

This is a known phenomenon in the Qurʾān and is done for agreement of verse-ending: the end of the verse is fitted to the sound of the preceding and following verses. The same elision is seen elsewhere too — al-kabīru'l-mutaʿāl (al-Raʿd 13/9), yawma yadʿu'd-dāʿ (al-Qamar 54/6).

It is transmitted that in the variant readings the word is read with the yāʾ as well (yasrī). There is no difference of meaning between the two readings. Since I cannot say with certainty which reading belongs to which authority, I write no name.

I should like to add an observation from the point of view of rhetoric, stating that it is my own reading: the cutting-off of the end of the word agrees with what it describes. The night travels and ends; and the word too is cut off before it is complete. That the sound should move together with the content is something often seen in the short Meccan sūras; but I record this not as a claim of miracle, but as the consistency of the text's formal choices.

Its being built with إِذَا

The oath is made not upon the night absolutely but upon one of its states: idhā yasri — "when it travels on."

This is an attitude seen in all the oaths of the sūra, and it is the same in al-Shams and al-Layl. The oath is made not upon the object but upon a particular moment of the object. Not the night itself but the night's travelling; not the morning itself but its splitting.

The result is this: what is sworn by is not an object but an event. And the common property of events is that they take place and pass.


The whole of Sūrat al-Fajr